A Reviewer Builds His Reference
System Part 2
Infrastructure Improvements Reviews of the JPS Labs cables, Analysis Audio outboard crossovers, Bybee Golden Goddess Interconnect Bullets, Ginkgo Audio isolation platforms and power conditioning.
Review By Wayne Donnelly
Click here to e-mail reviewer.
The
first chapter in this three-part series, as seen at
this link in the August Superior Audio,
narrated my transition from the San Francisco Bay area to Chicago, and
focused on the core components of my system, with full reviews of the VTL
TL-7.5 Series II line preamplifier and the Spectron Musician III Mk. II
amplifiers configured as monoblocks. This article reviews infrastructure
products that have delivered important improvements in connectivity,
component isolation and power conditioning.
Connectivity
When I initially set up my Chicago Loop
apartment, all of my interconnects and speaker cables were Jack Bybee's
Golden Goddess designs. Those remarkable-sounding hand-built cables
the interconnects incorporating Bybee Slipstream Quantum Purifiers
and gold +/silver - ribbon conductors; speaker cables using Bybee's Large
Gold Quantum Purifiers with high-purity copper conductors had
surpassed all contending cables I was able to compare, many of them
high-priced, from a number of highly regarded brands.
The Bybee cables sounded just as good in Chicago as in
California except for a problem that arose from my new location in the
heart of a major city. The Bybee cables were not shielded. Surprisingly,
that had not been a problem when I was living in Silicon Valley, although
that area is frequently cited as being beset by RFI/EMI noise
contamination. But my 12th floor Chicago digs in the downtown canyons were
truly under never-ending assault from such noise, both airborne and
through the electrical grid. So I decided to find well shielded
interconnects that could play in the same ballpark sonically with the
Bybee cables. I talked to colleagues and industry acquaintances, did a lot
of reading, and finally decided on alternative interconnects and speaker
cables.
JPS
Labs Superconductor 3 Interconnect & Speaker Cable
(1-meter RCA $999; 1-meter XLR $1099; 8 foot
speaker with WBT bananas $3099; Aluminata jumpers $400 for set of four)
Rather than copper, silver, gold or combinations of
those metals, JPS cables employ a proprietary alloy called Alumiloy. The
Superconductor 3 interconnects are not extremely flexible you can't
nearly kink 'em but sufficiently so that I had no trouble making all
necessary connections. The speaker cables are similar less flexible
than the Bybee cables I had been using, but again not problematical.
After a week-long burn-in on my trusty audiodharma Cable
Cooker, I installed the Superconductor 3 cables throughout the system. The
first thing I listened for was whether the hoped-for improvements in the
system's noise floor were evident and they were. The occasional
low-level sounds of radio broadcasts were now completely absent, and the
system's backgroud with nothing playng was noticeably "blacker."
That mission accomplished, I started listening for other cable-related
factors. One of the first things I noticed was that the system's spatial
resolution had gained slightly in layered depth, as well as image location
specificity. The broad and deep soundscape I was accustomed to had become
slightly wider and deeper; and on a well recorded CD like Alison
Krauss and Union Station Live, I could aurally "see"
the location of each band member ranged across the soundscape. I heard
similarly exciting location cues on symphonic and chamber music
recordings. Tonally, the sound of the JPS cables was remarkably similar to
that of the Bybee cables they had replaced. The Alumiloy conductors
sounded very much like the gold ribbon wire used in the Bybee Golden
Goddess Interconnects clean, fast and neutral, with just the right
touch of harmonic warmth.
The Superconductor 3 speaker cables delivered similarly
good results. My Analysis Amphitryon loudspeakers have bi-wire terminals,
so initially I put the JPS cables on the woofer panels and the Bybee
speaker cables on the ribbon tweeters. After a few days, I decided to take
out the Bybee speaker cables again, to see if the system noise floor
could be further improved and put in the JPS Aluminata jumpers. These
jumpers are very rigid, and must be bent into the desired form. The result
was gratifying another slight but discernible gain in overall
quietness, as well as deeper and tighter bass response.
A few months ago I went from a single stereo Spectron
Musician III by adding a second amplifier and configuring the two as
monoblocks. That setup requires that conventional speaker cables be
connected to the hot (+) side of both speaker terminals on the amplifier.
Around the same time I learned that Spectron and JPS were considering
having JPS produce premium Remote Sense speaker cables. (The Remote Sense
concept, unique to Spectron, extends the amplifier's feedback loop all the
way to the speaker, so that any nonlinearities in cables are corrected in
the amplifier's output. The Spectron amplifiers sport Neutrik Speak-On
twist-to-connect output terminals in addition to the conventional Cardas
terminals. I called Joe Scubinski, who told me he was prototyping two
Remote Sense cables, the best of which would also use Superconductor 3
wire. Joe agreed to send me a set for audition.
It took a while after I installed the new cables before
I could make a fair comparison with my original Superconductor 3s. Because
my Cable Cooker does not have an adapter for the Speak-On interface, I had
to burn in the new cables the slow, traditional way of just playing music
through them. Finally, after about three weeks of nearly 24/7 low-level
play, I was ready to compare Superconductor 3 in the standard and Remote
Sense versions. It was not much of a contest. With the Remote Sense cables
in place, leading-edge transients were faster and more impactful, and bass
response was deeper and even faster. I heard no negative trade-offs. This
result seems clearly to validate the Remote Sense concept, since the only
difference between the two cables is the amplifier/cable interface. I had
tried the original Spectron Remote Sense cables three years ago, but had
rejected them in favor of the Bybee cables. But those originals were
fabricated from off-the-shelf copper wire. The lesson here, for Spectron
users, is that all things being equal, Remote Sense works beautifully and
should be checked out.
I recently learned that Spectron and JPS, for business
reasons that I am not privy to, never finalized a deal. I understand that
Spectron is now working with another vendor (I don't know who) to develop
Remote Sense cables. When those are available, I will certainly audition
them. In the meantime, I am very happy to live with the JPS prototypes.
And Joe Scubinski tells me that if anyone wishes to order Remote Sense
speaker cables from him, he can supply them. Interested readers should
contact the two companies for details on price and availability.
JPS
Aluminata Interconnects
(1-meter RCA or XLR is $2999)
I had been hearing great things about the pricey
top-of-the-line JPS interconnects, but I ignored the scuttlebutt for
several months. After all, the Superconductor 3 cables were sounding
fabulous, and I wasn't eager to drop big bucks for what could surely be
only minor improvement. But a friend who is also a JPS dealer kept saying
that adding Aluminatas even in one location say, the preamp-to-amp
link would notably improve the system. Still, I resisted. What finally
made me sit up and take notice was hearing that Art Dudley, my old editor
at the late and much lamented Listener
Magazine, had given the Aluminatas an immoderate rave in a Stereophile
review. (I am not a fan of that magazine, but I have long respected
Artie's good ear and comon sense integrity.) In the Listener
days Art was highly skeptical, to say the least, about high-priced wire,
and Listener ran articles on
making cheap but good-sounding DIY cables. If that guy was dazzled by the
Aluminata cables, and not totally freaked by their price, I figured they
must be really special.
So I asked Joe Scubinski at JPS if I could audition a
couple of pairs of Aluminata interconnects, and they soon arrived. After a
week's burn-in on the Cable Cooker, in they went initially only on the
preamp-to-amp connection. Jaw-dropping time. The system noise floor had
been so lowered by the Superconductor 3 that I really hadn't expected a
significant incremental improvement from the Aluminata. But there it was
noticeably even quieter. I wondered briefly if I was falling prey to
"more expensive must be better" one of the more pernicious
hallmarks of that dreaded affliction audiophilia
nervosa. But after swapping back and forth a couple of times, I
confirmed that the Aluminata ICs did indeed make the system even quieter
than before.
That enhanced sense of quietness allowed even more very
low-level detail to emerge, but in a very natural, non-spotlit way. In
addition, every other benefit that the Superconductor 3 had delivered so
well went up another level. Spatial precision became a little more
concrete; bass response was now even deeper and tighter; and high
frequencies became more relaxed and open-sounding beautifully extended
but not bright. No, these three-times-more-costly Aluminata interconnects
were not three times better than the Superconductor 3 we all know that
in high-end audio, after a certain level you pay higher prices for smaller
gains but they were definitely better enough to make the investment
worthwhile for this perfection-seeking listener. After a few deep breaths
and a check of my bank balance, I ordered enough Aluminata for the entire
system. I've never been sorry.
Interestingly, I understand that the Superconductor 3
and Aluminata interconnects use the same Alumiloy conductors. The big
difference is in the shielding. The Superconductor 3 had been impressively
quiet in my heavily RFI/EMI-contaminated environment, but the further
improvements the Aluminata interconnects brought were substantial. I
especially love having them in my turntable-to-phono stage link, but they
have enhanced the sound of my digital sources and tuner as well. The
Aluminata ICs are bulkier than the Superconductor 3 (though equally
flexible); the reason for the bulkiness is the JPS Particle Aluminum
Shield, available only on the Aluminata cables. These are by far the
best-shielded and best-sounding cables I have ever used, and any
perfectionist audiophile who can afford them should check them out
whether or not system noise pollution is an issue.
Analysis
Audio Outboard Crossovers
($4800; Bybee SE Internal Bullet upgrade
is $2500)
These passive crossovers are designed
only
for the wonderful planar/ribbon Analysis loudspeakers imported from
Greece. But the crossovers themselves are the brainchild of Mike Kallelis
of Analysis Audio USA, the North American importer and distributor, who is
himself a talrnted engineer. Now, my Amphitryons ($28k per pair) sound
glorious with the original inboard 6 dB/octave first-order crossovers. I
bought them and gave them a 2006
Blue Note Award and my love affair with them has not cooled; I
still haven't heard any speakers I would rather live with, including
several big-ticket heavyweight contenders. So the rationale for the
outboard crossovers is not remedial the stock speakers have no
crossover-related issues that need "fixing." Rather, they take
an already great speaker to yet another level.
The crossovers occupy MDF enclosures measuring roughly 5
x 12 x 9 (HxDxW in inches). Both input from the amplifier and output to
the speakers are via the same terminals used on the speakers. Those
terminals are the only things I don't like about Analysis. Functionally,
they are five-way binding posts, but they are spaced a bit too close
together, they are round rather than hexagonal and therefore hard to
tighten effectively, and if removed, the tightening nuts look virtually
identical on both ends, so it's hard for my bad eyes to discern which end
should be out and if you put them in wrong it's hard to get a solid
connection with the WBT banana plugs on the speaker cables. I'm seriously
considering replacing all of them with WBT or Cardas terminals.
Like the stock crossovers, the outboard crossovers are
first-order. I don't recall all of the details on the components in them,
but the heavy-duty capacitors are Mundorf Silver. Mine have something
else, which is for now unique. For our 2008 Blue Note Awards I named the
Bybee Golden Goddess Speaker Bullets. As I said then, those pricey ($4200
per pair) little devices, which attach at the end of the speaker cables,
are the most dramatically effective revelatory, actually plug-in
accessories I have ever encountered. Mike confirmed that there was space
available inside the crossover enclosures, so we contacted Jack Bybee and
ordered eight of his SE Internal Bullets, which are used in in his plug-in
Golden Goddess SE Speaker Bullets, to be installed at the outboard
crossovers' output to the speakers. (Bybee restricts sales of those
devices to OEMs; they are not available for modifications. Mike Kallelis
has an OEM relationship with Bybee, and the crossovers are an OEM
product.)
If a customer orders the outboard crossovers when
purchasing the speakers, Mike Kallelis will make the necessary
modifications before shipping the speakers. That requires removing the
original internal crossovers. In my case, since I originally purchased the
stock Amphitryons, a retrofit was required. I did not want to take down
these seven-foot-tall screens, repack and ship them to New Jersey
which would also have been very expensive just for the shipping and
risk damaging the speakers, even though they are shipped in wood crates.
So, instead, I bought Mike a cheap round-trip ticket on Southwest and he
came out on a weekend and performed the necessary surgery. Removing
the internal crossovers, rewiring the speakers and installing the outboard
crossovers took a bit less than half a day, and I was ready to embark on
the lengthy task of burning in the new crossovers.
Mike had warned me that those big Mundorff capacitors
would require many hours of playing time to burn in fully, and I knew from
experience that the Bybee devices also require substantial burn-in time.
With that knowledge, I was not concerned when the speakers initially
sounded worse rather than better with the outboard crossovers in place
somewhat closed-in on top, with slower and less impactful bass, and a loss
of soundscape size and image specificity. Those qualities cleared up in
about 40-60 hours of playing time (and again, I left the system going
24/7, even playing very softly while I slept, for nearly a month). At
about the 100-hour mark the system began to bloom again, and I started to
get an idea of how the new crossovers would improve system performance.
But even after that, I continued to perceive incremental improvements over
the next three to four months.
Some time later it suddenly dawned on me that I could
have shortened the burn-in process considerably if I had put the
crossovers on the Cable Cooker, with speaker cables at the input and
output ends. I probably could have had the system performing at the
three-months-out level in a couple of weeks although, of course, I
wouldn't have been able to listen to the speakers during that time.
Once burn-in was complete, I was very happy that I had
made the investment. When I had decided to add the Bybee Internal Bullets
to the crossovers, I was thinking that I might be able then to sell the
original plug-in Speaker Bullets and recoup some of the cost of the
crossovers. So I tried removing the plug-in Bybee Bullets to see how good
the sound was with just the internal Bybees in the crossovers feeding
Aluminata jumpers to the speakers. The resultant sound was superb, but
after a few days I couldn't resist reattaching the plug-in Speaker Bullets
which meant I now had doubled up on the Bybee elements. I have been
incorporating Jack Bybee's amazing devices, both with internal component
modifications and Bybee cables and plug-in accesories, for nearly 15 years
now, and I have learned that their effects are cumulatively beneficial. So
it was no surprise to find that a double shot of Jack Bybee's most
advanced devices at the end of the system's signal path made things even
better than with just one set of Speaker Bullets.
Traditionally the major rationale for outboard
crossovers is to eliminate the resonances that can physically affect
crossover components, especially from the woofers. Such resonances can be
hard to overcome when the crossovers are inside a box speaker. There are
numerous ways of reducing such vibrations; two of my favorite past
speakers, the Eggleston Andras and the Meadowlark Blue Heron 2s, and many
other high-end loudspeakers, at least isolate the crossovers in separate
compartments under the speaker cabinet, as well as using various damping
materials. Because my Amphitryoens are dipole planer designs, they have no
resonating boxes. Moreover, the frames are quite sturdily built, and the
woofer panels and ribbons attach to the frame with a rubber surround that
further eliminates driver-generated vibration. Even the stock internal
crossovers are pretty free of resonance artifacts. That being the case,
the outboard crossovers need to provide serious additional sonic benefits
in order to justify the price.
I give the Analysis onboard crossovers a big
thumbs-up and Mission Accomplished (though I don't have an aircraft
carrier to hang a sign on). Adding the standard outboard crossovers to
these $28,000 speakers represents roughly a 17 percent upcharge; going
whole hog for the crossovers plus the Bybee Bullets takes the price up 26
percent. Even at $35,000 per pair, the Amphitryons bring me more musical
satisfaction than anything I have heard even at two or three times that
price.
It is very hard to quantify the qualitative improvements
I hear now, especially since after making the change there is no way to go
back and A/B the upgraded speakers with the originals. But having lived
with them for two years before the change and a year afterwards, I have no
doubt that the change was worth making. Every audio checklist factor one
typically cites in these reviews tonal purity, harmonic completeness,
transient speed and precision, bass depth, slam and pitch definition,
high-frequency openness and extension, spatial verisimilitude is now
clearly enhanced. Every listening session draws me instantly into the
music, nourishing my soul. And when my critical duties mandate shifting
into left-brain analytical mode, these speakers are a fantastic reviewer's
tool, allowing me to discern the most subtle differences among other
components and accessories. My "window into the sound" is pretty
damn clear!
Bybee Golden Goddess
'Super Effect' RCA and XLR Interconnect Bullets
(both $2495 per pair); Bybee
EL RCA Interconnect Bullets ($890 per pair)
First, some general information. The two Golden Goddess
products use the same SE Internal Bullets as the Bybee Golden
Goddess Speaker Bullets referenced above and discussed in conjunction with
the Analysis outboard crossovers in the previous section. Their primary
function is to eliminate 1/f noise, a form of quantum mechanical noise
caused when electrons flow through conductive materials. This noise is not
audible to the human ear, but it negatively affects the beauty and
musicality of program material. Eliminating 1/f noise allows music to play
back with more natural immediacy and impact, without the subtly degrading
electronic "haze" that otherwise overlays even the most
high-quality audio systems.
These new Bybee products also perform a subtle but
valuable time-alignment function. High frequencies propagate through
cables at a slightly faster rate than do low frequencies. All of three
Bybee Golden Goddess SE Bullet products incorporate a 21-picosecond
dispersive delay that realigns those high and low frequencies to give
musical signals a more coherent presentation. While the human ear cannot
perceive a 21-picosecond misalignment in isolation, this restoration of
timing can be heard in the more impactful and coherent reproduction of
program material. The SE internal devices used in the Golden Goddess SE
Bullets are custom-fabricated using gold, silver and platinum. Each GG SE
RCA Bullet has a 3-inch carbon fiber tube, with an Eichmann RCA plug and
jack at each end, SE Internal Bullets on both the + and - legs, and 14K
gold ribbon wire.
When Jack Bybee told me, about a year ago, that he was
developing a product for interconnects that would do what his Speaker
Bullets had done for speaker cables, I knew I had to audition them. Even
though, as described above, the JPS Aluminata interconnects were
performing brilliantly, and had gone a long way toward transforming my
system's noise floor to a new degree of quietness, I still felt that I was
missing some of the "magical" musicality that my former
unshielded Bybee interconnects had contributed. Jack sent me a couple of
pairs to audition, and after a one-week burn-in on the Cable Cooker I
initially installed one pair, at the inputs of my (before the monoblocks)
Spectron amplifier. I tried the other pair alternately from the CD player
and phono stage links to my preamplifier. Lovely as the system had
sounded, I knew almost instantly after adding these GG RCA Bullets that I
had been right about missing something. With the RCA Bullets added to the
Aluminata interconnects, the magic was back, in spades! I have already
discussed the remarkable benefits of Jack Bybee's signal purification
technology. The best way I can think of to boil it down it is to say that
these products move the system's sound away from sounding
"electronic" and toward pure musicality. I bought the two
audition pairs, and after going to monoblock amplifiers, bought another
pair. The RCA Bullets now reside at the inputs to both amplifiers and at
the preamplifier's CD input.
The Golden Goddess SE XLR Bullets are intended not only
for perfectionist audiophile systems, but also to improve the fidelity of
the recording process itself, from basic signal capture through mixing,
mastering and manufacturing. Connected at the downstream end of microphone
or interconnect cables, the SE XLR Bullets are designed to provide an
unprecedented degree of quietness, coherence and tonal fidelity in any
recording or playback environment.
Each SE XLR Bullet has a carbon fiber cylinder, five
inches long and two inches in diameter. A Neutrik female XLR connector is
set into the receiving end of the cylinder. At the other end, a short
length of premium cable, with reinforced strain relief, terminates in a
Neutrik male XLR connector. Jack Bybee tells me that it took him a long
time to figure out how to build those devices and keep the price in the
same ballpark as the RCA Bullets. I wanted to try them because I wanted to
use balanced interconnects between my Ray Samuels Emmeline XR-10B phono
stage and preamplifier, in order to take advantage of the common-mode
noise rejection of balanced cables. In late spring of this year I received
a pair, "cooked" them for a week and installed them. Same lovely
old song while the phono sound had been quite satisfying, and quiet,
with the JPS interconnect, I got the predictable improvements in beauty
and musicality with the XLR Bullets.
I do not make live recordings, so I have no way of
testing whether the XLR Bullets are as effective in that environment as
they are in a playback system. But Jack Bybee has taken them for beta
testing in a professional recording environment, and he forwarded to me
some informal e-mail comments from noted record producer Cookie Marenco
after she used the XLR Bullets in her studio. With more than 20 years in
the music industry, Cookie Marencos creative and technical skills have
touched almost every aspect of the business. She is widely known for the
quality of her audio engineering skills and for drawing out passionate
performances from the artists she produces. She has engineered or produced
5 Grammy-nominated records, several Gold records and an Academy
Award-winning documentary. Her artist credits include Max Roach, Kenny
Aronoff, Tony Furtado, Charlie Haden, Ralph Towner, Ernie Watts,
Mary Chapin Carpenter, Chanticleer, and Ladysmith Black Mambazo. Her
production and engineering skills can be found on projects for Monterey
Jazz Festival, Telluride Bluegrass Festival, Marinfest, Midem, Hard Rock
Cafe, Windham Hill Records, Verve, Rounder Records, Om Records, Sony,
Warner Bros. and others.
"When we tested
the Bullets on the piano, we noticed a smoothness to the high notes that
we never believed existed. Several of us heard the difference.
We replayed the test many times to make sure of what we were hearing.
We're looking forward to trying out the Bullets in every place in the
recording chain from microphones to mastering inputs."
"I had another
opportunity to put the Bullets to the maximum test the other day. I
was mixing a project at OTR that was recorded at the artist's home studio
on Protools. Always an adventure! While there wasn't apparent
clipping issues, the sound appeared distorted, midrange exaggerated and
really horrible. I tried the usual method of running both stereo
channels through my Millennia Origins and equalizing as usual. The
sound was better, but still quite annoying, so, I thought to run the
Bullets into the Millennia before the signal arrived back at the board. We
were all amazed, including the artist. The immediate improvement was
astounding!
I then tried using a
Bullet in the same config with the lead vocal, which had run to the edge
of what the Neumann 87 could handle. Again, very beautiful sound.
I have my ideas of what changes the sound made, but, before I say all
that, I must first thank you for letting me test these wonderful
units."
"We were
recording a solo harp for a few days. More than the piano, the harp
can have fine distortion characteristics that I had always attributed to
the artist's performance of the 'pluck'. After 2 days of recording,
I asked the artist to perform the same piece and I inserted the Bullets
into the Neve preamps coming from the BK 4012 silver cable config i use
for the piano.... Everyone agreed in the room that the sound was brighter,
slightly louder and much smoother. The upper end distortion seemed
to be gone.
This wasn't a well
prepared test, but getting used to the 'old' sound, then hearing the same
instrument with the same mic and same performer with no physical moves on
the board... it was impressive. We all felt it enhanced and
improved the sound of the harp. More noticeable than the piano, in fact.
The harp would be a
good instrument to test on in the future. I wonder how many harpists
there are in the world? Every harp player should carry these Bullets
to recordings!!!!
Unfortunately, we are not likely to find many recordings
that use the XLR Bullets, even after results such as those described
above. Generally, pro sound folks just won't spend the money for a product
at this price point. But we can dream....
The EL (Entry-Level) RCA Bullets are designed to provide
Bybee signal purification at a much lower cost than the Golden Goddess
products. Physically, they resemble their costlier siblings. Each EL RCA
Bullet has a 3-inch-long carbon fiber tube containing a Neutrik RCA plug
and Cardas RCA jack. A Bybee Slipstream Purifier is placed on the positive
leg, and high-purity copper wiring is used.
The EL RCA Bullets work well in all applications, but
Jack Bybee especially recommends them for phono cables. However, the
low-level signals generated by photo cartridges would require an
excessively long burn-in to reach optimal performance. Before placing the
EL RCA Bullets on phono cables, Jack recommends a 100-hour burn-in in a
preamp-to-amp connection or on a cable burn-in appliance. I heartily
concur.
My phono preamp has RCA inputs and both RCA and XLR
outputs. I wanted to try the EL RCA Bullets at the phono input from the
turntable; as described above, I have XLR connection from the photo preamp
to my line stage. Upon installing these lower-cost Bullets, I did in fact
quickly perceive a subtle but definitely worthwhile "Bybee
effect" here as well. And that was after all the other upgrades I
have been discussing in this article. I think there are few systems, at
whatever price, that would not gain in musicality from a judicious
application of these moderately priced EL RCA Bullets. I added another
pair to my tuner connection, abd the suberb broadcast sound of Chicago's
great classical FM station WFMT predictably improved so much so that a
visitor who came in onr day while the tuner was playing asked me for
"the name of that beautiful CD." Alright!
A
Final Comment On Connectivity: Continuity And Coherence
After integrating all of the products
covered in this section, I feel that I have achieved a remarkable degree
of continuity and coherence in my system's signal path. Let me explain.
The Spectron amplifiers and the Analysis outboard crossovers are wired
internally with JPS Labs wire. This wire is available selectively to OEM
customers, NOT to modifiers or DIYers. As a result, my entire signal path
flows through wire, cables and accessories from JPS Labs and Bybee
Technologies. Obviously, I could at this point do only limited comparative
testing. But I believe strongly that this consistency provides valuable
continuity that enhances the remarkable sense of coherence I hear from the
system.
Isolation
Anyone who takes this hobby seriously soon
learns how important are component isolation and vibration control to
getting the best out of an audio system. It's really quite extraordinary
that even behemoth, virtually unliftable amplifiers lose some of their
expensively engineered performance from even very tiny degrees of
vibration. Consequently, isolation and vibration control products comprise
one of the biggest segments of aftermarket accessory sales.
After nearly four decades as an audiophile, I'm not sure
I could even remember all of the devices all made and purchased
that I have tried over the years. Racks, cones, pods, pucks, balls,
blocks, platforms. Made from many different combinations of metals,
plastics, rubberr, graphite, vinyl, air well, you know. If I still had
all that stuff I could probably fill a small closet with it.
When I arrived in Chicago my equipment rack was the
Arcici Suspense Rack I had purchased some 13 years earlier. Conceptually,
this is a very ingenious and effective design. Virtually nonresonant
acrylic shelves, dampened by Sorbothane support disks, are suspended via
metal rods from a massive steel plate that sits atop four wheelbarrow
inner tubes that can be inflated with a hand-held bicycle pump from valves
on the front of the rack. In that way every component in the rack is
effectively air-suspended, as is the turntable sitting atop the rack.
Over the years this rack has required constant tweaking.
The valves leak, usually not quickly but enough that maintaining effective
air suspension requires re-pumping every few days. And a few years ago I
had to replace all of the inner tubes with new ones. These days, given my
poor eyesight, trying to judge just the right degree of inflation (too
much pumping up reduces the effectiveness; the key is to inflate just
enough). So I thought the rack could use a little help.
Back when I was using the big VTL tube monoblocks, they
were way too large to fit into a rack, so I placed them on individual
Arcici air-suspension platforms. I also, typically, had numbers of
separate component power supply modules sitting on the floor. But after
going from the big VTL amps to the Spectron amplifiers, which are easily
accommodated on a component rack, I decided to keep everything off the
floor. In California I had maintained a small separate system upstairs in
my bedroom, surrounding my big flat-screen TV. The components in that
small system had resided in a sturdy Sanus rack with rigidly fixed
shelves. I decided to add that rack to the main system, which allowed me
to get everything electronic off the floor.
I knew, though, that given the high power of my
amplifiers and the excellent bass output of my speakers, that I needed
very good isolation support for the components. I didn't want a hodgepodge
of footers, but rather a solution that would be consistent in effect and
appearance. And I didn't want to have to spend a fortune. After a good bit
of research, review reading and conversation, I finally decided on what to
do.
Ginkgo
Audio Vibration Control Platforms
Cloud 10 (18 x 14 x 2.5") $329
Cloud 11 (18 x 16 x 2.5") $449
Cloud 11 for VPI Aries 3 turntable: $599
Mini-Cloud (3 support balls, no platform) $100
A Ginkgo platform comprises a dimpled base that enables
the user to place precisely solid, firm balls roughly the size of a
racquetball to support a solid plastic platform on which the component
rests. The number of balls needed depends on the weight of the component
roughly one ball for every 10 pounds supported. When I received my first
shipment from Ginkgo, I couldn't resist a smile. Years ago I had
jury-rigged more than one similarly conceived device using racquetballs
and tennis balls and they had actually worked pretty well.
As you can see from the dimensions, the Cloud 11 is two
inches deeper than the Cloud 10, and has a thicker, heavier platform. I
put 11s under my Spectron amplifiers as well as under both chassis of my
VTL 7.5 preamp, which weigh @ 40 pounds each. Cloud 10s support my CD
player and (with a little extra weight added) the VPI SDS speed
controller for my Aries 3 turntable. I have used the Mini-Clouds (3
ball/footer combos, no platform) under my tuner and outboard power
supplies. Finally, a Ginkgo platform designed specifically for the Aries 3
sits under the turntable.
Those placements were done one at a time, which enabled
a succession of before-and-after comparisons. I must say that I was
(agreeably) shocked at the degree of improvements in the system wrought by
these simple structures. The most noticeable effect, in virtually every
case, was a gain in transparency. I had not thought my system sounded
congested, but when that congestion was eliminated, music sounded
distinctly clearer and more beautiful. Spatial cues were far more precise,
and imaging from a very good recording could be almost holographic. Bass
response grew quicker, tighter and more impactful, and transients at any
frequency gained a more sharply defined leading edge.
I also like the security of having my components sit on
substantial surfaces, in no danger of having a small footer dislodged. And
I like the visual consistency of the platforms. (They are available in
clear or black plastic; I opted for the black.)
A word about the Mini-Clouds: I find those inexpensive
supports a fine improvement over placing the component directly on a
shelf. But when I replaced a set of them with a Cloud 10 under my VPI SDS
where I hadn't thought vibration control would make much of a difference
the sound of the turntable immediately improved in transparency, bass
control and high-frequency openness. Go figure. So I suspect that before
long the Mini-Clouds will be replaced by platforms.
The dedicated Aries 3 Gingko platform has beautifully
isolated my turntable. Recently, however, I have been evaluating the new
VPI rim drive motor (review in progress), which is a bit longer than the
single-motor-flywheel drive, and the Ginkgo platform is just barely wide
enough to support that rig. So I ordered a 1.5-inch-thick hard maple
butcher block to more comfortably accommodate the VPI setup, and now have
the butcher block shelf between the Ginkgo platform and the turntable. It
was easy enough I just added two more balls to support the extra
weight of the butcher block. And, as I suspected, the combination of the
Ginkgo isolation and the slight harmonic warmth from the butcher block is
bringing me even more pleasure from my LPs than before.
Power
Conditioning
When I reviewed the Bybee Wire Power
Purifier (see the Blue Note Awards in this
issue), I described having my
original Bybee/Curl Pro power conditioner updated with the same Bybee SE
Internal Bullets I discussed earlier in this article. That
excellent-sounding conditioner now serves all of my front-end and source
components. In addition, virtually everything in my system uses Bybee
power cables.
When I originally planned this series of articles, I
expected to provide a fairly lengthy discussion of the ExactPower
EP-15A, two of which reside in my system. But several weeks ago I received
a letter stating that the EP-15A is now discontinued. A full review
is now irrelevant, but I will discuss the virtues of this product more
briefly.
The acquisition of the EP-15A units was prompted by the
discovery back in late 2007 that my Chicago building has a chronic
overvoltage electrical service. During the day the incoming AC typically
ranges between 123 and 127V, which is far from ideal but well within the
tolerances of most well designed audio gear. But in the evening, when I do
most of my serious listening, incoming AC is typically in excess of 130V
and that is not healthy for audio electronics. Over the long haul, that
much excessive voltage as potential to prematurely degrade parts and lead
to expensive repairs.
I selected the EP-15A primarily because it was a
voltage-regulating design, able to take incoming AC from 95 to 140V and
regulate that to produce an output of 120V to all outlets. The EP-15A also
supplied 10 AC outlets, divided equally between analog and digital the
latter with special filtering. In use, the voltage regulation works
perfectly, and the unit's RFI/EMI filtering was quite useful in combating
that kind of noise contamination. I also felt that putting the EP-15A
units (I have two, because a single EP-15A, with a total rating of 150 W,
would occasionally clip and shut down when the system was playing very
loudly. But it was clear to me that the EP-15As made a useful
contribution to the overall sound quality of the system as well.
In my current setup, the EP-15As are plugged
directly into the wall. The Bybee/Curl Pro, which has separate circuits
for analog and digital components, is plugged into the EP-15As, analog
side into one and digital side into the other. The two Spectron amplifiers
also plug into the EP-15As, one amp into each unit.
I was sorry to learn that this fine product is now
discontinued. It is an attractive and well made unit. Anyone looking for a
good power conditioner, especially if voltage regulation is needed, would
be well advised to look for it on the used equipment auction sites.
Click here for part 3 of Building
A Reference System.
Manufacturers
www.JPSlabs.com
www.AnalysisAudioUSA.com
www.BybeeTech.com
www.GingkoAudio.com