North American Premiere
Rossner & Sohn Canofer-S Phono Preamplifier
Reveling in the natural timbre of ensembles both large and small.
Review By Tom Lyle
Click
here to e-mail reviewer.
The first thing that
came to mind when I sat down to write this review of the excellent Rossner
& Sohn Canofer-S phono preamplifier, was that when it comes to
evaluating the sound quality of solid-state equipment at this level,
especially when pitting one against the other, it can be a tough sell
convincing myself whether one can be considered more "correct"
sounding than the other. Yes, there are differences, but I'm more
comfortable stating that they represent different versions of coming close
to the elusive sonic truth. Of course there are other differences that are
less intangible, such as features, and of course, the asking price (and
inevitably the law of diminishing returns). At $7300 the Rossner &
Sohn Canofer-S is not in the "affordable" category for most
listeners, but with this phono preamplifier one gets top-notch sound,
convenient front panel controls, and a superbly constructed unit that is
designed, built, and imported from Germany.
I located the Canofer-S for the duration of
the review period on its own shelf on an Arcici Suspense equipment rack.
The turntable was a Basis Debut V with a Lyra Helikon cartridge mounted on
a Tri-Planar VII U tonearm. The preamplifiers was either a tubed Balanced
Audio Technology (BAT) VK-3iX or Acousticbuoy Scorpion, or a solid-state
Burson Audio PPE-160, and the power amplifiers either a Krell KAV-250a or
Emotiva XPA-2. Speakers were the Sound Lab DynaStat electrostatic/dynamic
hybrids, augmented by a Velodyne HGS-15b subwoofer. The tonearm is
hardwired with Cardas, but the rest of the system uses a mix of Virtual
Dynamics and MIT interconnects and speaker cable. Front end's power cords,
including that of the phono preamp was hooked up to a PS Audio AC
regenerator, with a separate PSA regenerator for the turntable, and the
Velodyne's power cord was connected to a Chang Lightspeed power
conditioner. The dedicated listening room is treated with Echo Buster
acoustic panels, and has two dedicated 15 Ampere lines.
Main
Assets
One of the main assets of the
Canofer-S
(besides its great sound, of course) is its flexibility. On the front
panel of this rather large component with an outboard power supply are
three 24-position rotary controls labeled Resistor,
Gain, and Increase.
These 24 position controls with a very high-caliber feel, enable one
to choose a whole slew of loading possibilities that will match just about
any phono cartridge on the planet. The Resistor
control varies the input resistance from 22 to a whopping -75k Ohms, When
I asked the distributor of the Canofer-S for the actual gain and
resistance values which correspond to each notched setting, I was told
that there are simply too many computations (over 1800 just for the
typical MC cartridge) to compute these values. According to the
manufacturer, they recommend that the user of the Canofer-S let one's ears
be the judge rather than the particular values of each setting — and
state that their design philosophy is to allow the user to make
"adjustments on the fly". The Increase
control had me stumped for a while. In the manual it suggests using this
control to set this control to vary the amount of bass that is reproduced
by the phono preamp, starting with the setting at the neutral 12 o'clock
position. So that's what I did. And yes, moving the control did affect the
amount of bass, but later learned from the distributor that this control
is actually an oft forgotten phase control. I'm not sure if it
technologically correct (and there is a good chance that I'm wrong about
this) that a phase control can be variable like this one here, rather than
just the usual positive or negative positions usually available. I tried
adjusting it for each recording for a while, but without some sort of
guide I was a bit lost as what was "accurate" other than just
trusting my ears, and yes, after a while I realized that the 12 o'clock
position was just fine.
Rossner & Sohn have loaded the rather
large Canofer-S and its external power supply with "the best"
German and Swiss internal parts with recognizable names such as Mundorf
Supreme caps, Elma switches with gold plating, and WBT Nextgen connectors.
The main circuit board of the Canofer-S is suspended by aluminum columns,
then those columns are mounted on a separate aluminum plate, and then the
plate is then fixed to a silicone pad. The main circuit board is coated
with a "special" resin for damping and shielding, and there are
two separate amplifiers for each channel. The Canofer-S has a 2mm thick
steel plate for the housing which further reduces electrical and radio
interference, and they describe the transformer as a "hand
selected" vacuum sealed, two chamber coil. On the rear panel are
single-ended RCA inputs and outputs, a connection for the tonearm's
ground, and an input for the power supply umbilical.
The owner of Excel Stereo, the importer of
Rossner & Sohn was nice enough to drop off the Canofer-S at my home on
his way to visit some retailers in my area. After we set up the phono
preamplifier, we spun a couple of records, and to be blunt neither of us
was impressed. Some of this was probably due to some equipment mismatches
due to me playing component-musical-chairs with the system at the time.
But the main reason was undoubtedly that while breaking-in this phono
preamplifier the sound changed for the better dramatically. I'm not
exaggerating here — I've never heard an audio product undergo such a
radical change from when I first placed it in the system to well after I
thought its sound was leveling off. The potential owner of a Canofer-S
should keep this in mind and be very, very patient. I'm apologize: I did
not log how many LP sides it took, nor do I recall exactly how many
calendar days had passed, but I would guess that I spun more than 200
hours of records before I was convinced that I've reached its full
potential.
Worth
And it was worth the wait. On every
decent record that I played took on not only what I believe to be a
transparent representation of what was etched into the vinyl, but at the
same time real instruments sounded like real instruments, which is the
highest praise I could ever bestow on a piece of gear. On the EMI LP of
Andre Previn conducting William Walton's Belshazzar's
Feast, the first half of side one is taken up by the lesser
known Improvisations on an Impromptu of
Benjamin Britten. Before hearing this piece I assumed it would
simply be an homage to Britten, but other than citing the theme it is very
Waltonian (I thought I invented this word, but there it was in the liner
jacket's liner notes). During many parts of the score the orchestra
explodes in tonal bursts, which tested not only the phono preamp's
transient response but the system as a whole, and the Canofer-S passed
this test with ease. All the while, every instrument in the orchestra on
this great recording, engineered and produced by the team of Bishop and
Parker, had a natural presence in not only each instrument's tonal
character, but in the placement of each instrument (and group of
instruments) in the expansive soundstage. I could go on citing all the
audiophile-approved aphorisms, but you get the idea — there were quite a
few times in during the review period that I thought that this phono stage
seemed to simply pass on the information passed onto it from the cartridge
and amplified the signal with very, very little editorializing or even
better, no sonic embellishment.
Side two of Led Zeppelin's untitled fourth
LP (sometimes called "IV", sometimes called "Zoso",
and sometimes called "Ruins"), thankfully skipping side one's
"Stairway To Heaven", is a record that I must have heard about
three thousand times during my lifetime. But I can honestly say that
through the Canofer-S it sounded the best I've ever heard it — from John
Bohnam's bone-crushing drums on the slide-guitar driven "Misty
Mountain Hop", the acoustic and electric guitar/snareless
drum-set/synthesizer overdubbed madness of "Four Sticks", the
Anglo-folk mandolin and twelve-string guitar "Going To
California", and especially guitarist/producer Jimmy Paige's mondo
"bottom of the staircase and up the hallway" drum-intro
extravaganza "When The Levee Breaks", which annihilated any
stray inert air molecules in the listening room. No, this isn't an
audiophile product in the way one usually associates the term because of
its recording studio trickery, and although intentional, the sound quality
changes from song to song and sometimes even within the same song. John
Paul Jones' Fender Jazz bass sounds rather indistinct and Robert Plant's
vocals sound (at best) like they've been re-equalized and otherwise
processed, but damn, does this album rock through the Canofer-S. This is
in large part due to this phono preamp's transparency to the nth power,
combined with a devastating delivery of all that is rock 'n' roll by way
of this album, transferred to the rest of the system with its three
dimensional mad-made soundstage intact. One of the joys as an audiophile
is being able to listen to recordings I've heard since my childhood
rendered with not only newly discovered details, but such a lifelike
sound. I'm rarely bored.
The infinite range of settings that were
possible via the Canofer-S's front panel controls was both a curse and a
blessing, as you can imagine when such options are offered to the
potentially obsessive personality of an audiophile. For instance, at times
the Canofer-S displayed a paradoxical anomaly of having a very typically
solid-state ultra-detailed slightly dry sound, and at the same time had an
oh, so slightly tipped up mid-bass. This was not evident on every
recording I played, so it would be wrong to condemn this phono preamp with
such a description, although its character definitely leaned toward the
solid-state. I did spend some time futzing with the resistance control
more than anything else, and it would would sometimes change the sound
rather than improve it, since it was pretty tough making the Canofer-S
sound anything other than first-rate. But sometimes after making some
adjustments I'd throw on a different recording and find that I preferred
it with a setting that I didn't settle on previously. Later I'd come back
to that recording, and find that another setting that I'd never tried
before, perhaps in conjunction with a slight decrease or increase in the
gain, and that would be the ticket to getting sound more to my liking.
Please believe me, I'd rather enjoy the
music (sorry) than mess with settings all day. In most cases I'd
eventually find a setting I could live with. But since I don't make
adjustments for VTA for different record thicknesses (although I have
nothing against folks who do), I rarely make make adjustments for to the a
phono preamp's controls too often once I've found a setting that I'm happy
with. So after the initial period where I would obsess over the settings,
I settled down and just reveled in the natural timbre elicited by just
about every orchestral and jazz recording by ensembles large and small.
And if the sounds were man-made (that is synthesized, EQ'd, or otherwise
created in the recording studio) they sounded as if I was coming as close
as I ever had to what the recording engineer, producer, mastering
engineer, and especially the musicians intended me to hear. The detail
that was retrieved by this phono stage was stupendous. I'd also be remiss
not to mention the Canofer-S's fine rendering of vocals, both male and
female.
Resulting
Even
though the resulting sound of a component is really what should matter
most, as things may raise an eyebrow or two. Most, if not all phono
preamplifiers that I've seen in this price category have had more than one
input and when I first read about the Canofer-S I assumed that the
variable controls on the front panel were to calibrate the unit for
different tonearm/cartridge combinations that might be located in one's
system. But Rossner & Sohn claims they have not been satisfied with
any switches that were available that were good enough for them to use as
an input selector. This problem solved, they are now currently designing a
new phono preamplifier that will have more than one input and as of this
writing are in the prototype stage of development. Secondly, the majority
of components in the price range of the Canofer-S have at least a balanced
XLR output plus perhaps a balanced input. The tonearm I used has an
unbalanced RCA cable, so that didn't bother me, but I would have liked at
least a balanced output on the phono preamp to connect an XLR cable to the
BAT preamp. Lastly, a mono switch would have been nice, not to mention a
remote control. Although I'd rather not assume anything, I have a pretty
good idea that Rossner & Sohn would proclaim that adding these
features would lessen the fidelity of the unit, and I would agree that the
loss of these two controls are worth sacrificing them for sound quality,
plus, the price of the unit would undoubtedly be higher. These complaints
aside (and they really wouldn't be complaints if this phono preamplifier
didn't cost so darn much) I honestly think that the Canofer-S is a phono
preamplifier that every vinyl loving audiophile should make a point to
audition. If one can afford it, they should consider giving it a permanent
place on their equipment rack.
Specifications
Type: Solid-state phonostage
Frequency Response: 0 Hz - 40 kHz
Input Sensitivity: Moving Magnet -40 dB, Moving Coil -60 dB
Input Impedance (MM) 50k/90 pF
Maximum Input Voltage: 110 mV
RIAA Accuracy: greater than +- 0.15 dB
Signal To Noise Ratio: 88 dB relating to 0.775 V
Enclosure Material: Aluminum
Dimensions: 17 x 4 x 10.5 (WxHxD in inches)
Price $7300
Company Information
Hans Rossner & Sohn GmbH
Ulmer Str. 11
D-87700 Memmingen
Phone: +49 (0)8331 / 88877
Fax: +49 (0)8331 / 48589
E-Mail: info@rossner-und-sohn.de
Internet: www.rossner-und-sohn.de
North American Distributor
Laurenity Marketing
7321 Victoria Park Avenue, Unit 15
Markham
Ontario L3R 2Z8
Canada
Voice: (416) 847-5011
E-mail: info@laurenity.com
Website: www.laurenity.com